Commercial Rockets

ARIANE — EU, 1979

This is the signature rocket of the European Space Agency. Though developed by an intergovernmental initiative, it was the first orbital rocket system to be operated for commercial profit (though with substantial governmental support), by Arianespace SA in France, which now also sells some Soyuz launches. The first Ariane flew in 1979. Versions 1 through 4 were based on France’s Diamant rocket, after Britain withdrew its Blue Streak booster. It was the first rocket whose design was primarily guided by the mission of launching commercial satellites, particularly geostationary ones, in direct competition with the Space Shuttle. The Arianes pioneered the technique of launching more than one satellite per flight — even Ariane 1 could do two geostationary satellites per flight. The Ariane 4 had a long run: 116 launches with just three failures.

The current Ariane 5 is an all-new design, dropping much of the legacy of models 1–4. It’s bigger than a Proton, though not as big as a Long March 5. Like the space shuttle, the “Vulcain 2” main engine is hydrogen fueled, and it is always launched with a pair of very large solid-fuel boosters on the sides. (The old Arianes used hypergolic fuel.) The Vulcain’s thrust is low: less than a tenth what the pair of solid boosters puts out. The boosters use aluminum bound in HTPB and have steerable nozzles. They’re built in three segments and use a steel casing.

The second stages originally used hypergolic fuel (monomethylhydrazine), but lately they’ve come up with a much bigger one that burns hydrogen, called ESC-A (Etage Supérieur Cryotechnique de type A), or just ECA for short. It was first used on Ariane 4. So far they only use this for single payloads to GTO, as its engine is not restartable, so they also modernized the hypergolic stage for low-orbit work. This version is called ES. The majority of launches now use ECA. The Ariane 5 is rated for human flight, but has never been used for this purpose. The cancelled Hermes spaceplane was supposed to be launched with it. The 5’s success rate started out rough, but they’ve been nearly spotless since 2002 — the worst “failure” being a guidance error made on the ground which resulted in a slightly wrong orbit.

Arianes do not launch from Europe. The spaceport they use is in French Guiana, near the equator, on land that used to be part of the notorious prison colony there. The big solid boosters are manufactured right there at the launch center.

Ariane 6 is in development, and aims to be very competitive in cost per payload ton. They announced plans for it to have a main engine section that can detach itself from its tanks and land on a runway with little wings, thus recovering the majority of the money spent on the first stage. It would have little propellers and wheels tucked away inside it. This idea is known as “Project ADELINE” (a tortured acronym not worth spelling out).

But now they’re saying that the Adeline recovery trick will have to wait for Ariane 7. Ariane 6 should still be substantially cheaper than Ariane 5, though. For starters, it’s smaller — particularly the solid boosters, which will have the option of being used as a pair or a quad, so as to match the 5’s capacity. These shorter side boosters are a variant of the first stage of the capacity. These shorter side boosters are a variant of the “P80” first stage of the Vega, and are HTPB and aluminum in a single piece, encased in carbon fiber 25 centimeters thick. The nozzle is an update of the one from the old booster, and and it’s assembled and filled at the same facility in Guiana.

The new reusable engine is going to be called “Prometheus”. It will be cheaply 3D-printed, and burn methane. And in parallel with the development of the ADELINE trick, another project will (if they get the funding) be building a test booster to try to fly back and land vertically like the Falcon 9 does. This experimental hopper will be called “Themis”, and will also use the Prometheus engine. This will persumably happen some time after they do some initial flyback experimenting with a much smaller “Callisto” hopper which they announced earlier. This baby hopper will let them make their first efforts at flyback landing more inexpensively.

The Ariane 6 will use an ESC-B upper stage, updated with a new “Vinci” engine which is restartable up to five times.

Ariane 5 ECA: mass 780 t, diam 5.4 m (width 11.5 m), thrust 13000 kN, imp 4.2 km/s (core), type Gh+S, payload 19.3 t (2.5%), cost $7M/t, record 243/0/11 (106/0/4 for 5+).
Stage name EAP-E EPC H173 EPS L10 * ESC-A
Role (pos) count booster (S) ×2 core (1) upper (2) upper (2)
Diameter (m)   3.06   5.40   5.40   5.40
Liftoff mass (t) 273    185    11.2 19.4
Empty mass (t) 33   14.7  1.2  4.5
Fuel mass (t) ~72    ~22    ~3.4 ~2.4
Oxidizer mass (t) ~169     ~151     ~6.6 ~12.2 
Fuel type HTPB+aluminum hydrogen MMH hydrogen
Engine EAP P241 Safran
Vulcain 2
Aestus Snecma
Power cycle solid gas gen (GN) pressure-fed gas gen
Chamber pres. (bar) 100    11   37  
Ox./fuel ratio   2.3?   6.70   1.90   5.00
Thrust, vac max (kN) 6470     1350     27   67  
Thrust, SL initial (kN) 5975     960   
Spec. imp, vac (km/s)   2.70   4.24   3.18   4.38
Total imp, vac (t·km/s) 1312     737    31.3 63.5